Skip to content
Menu

Who may give visa advice is a legal question.

A student asks how to present an old refusal. The kindest, most experienced answer may be one the counsellor has no right to give.

Visatory · · 5 min read

Who may give visa advice is a legal question.
Photograph by Magic Fan on Unsplash.

A student with an offer asks her counsellor a reasonable question. She was refused a visa for the same country two years ago, and she wants to know how to explain it on the new application and whether a different visa category would be safer. The counsellor has been doing this for eight years. He answers, kindly and with confidence. In several destinations, what he has just given may be immigration advice, from somebody not authorised to give it.

Education agents tend to treat the visa as part of the service, because families expect it and because the student cannot enrol without one. The reasoning is understandable and the assumption underneath it is dangerous. Recommending a course and advising somebody on their immigration position are different activities, and a number of destinations regulate the second one separately.

The line is about whose position is being advised on.

Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United Kingdom each restrict who may give immigration advice, through a system of registered, licensed or authorised advisers. The detail differs: who is covered, whether the rule reaches somebody outside the country, whether payment matters, and what exemptions exist for education providers or their agents. An exemption you have not read is not one you have. Other destinations handle this differently, and the agency's home country may regulate study-abroad services in its own right.

A working distinction keeps most offices on the right side, though a regulator may draw the line elsewhere. Explaining what is published is information. Applying the rules to one person's circumstances and telling them what to do is advice. A counsellor can say what a checklist requires. Telling a student with a previous refusal how to present it is another matter.

What a counsellor can answer, and what to refer.

Keep this list next to the phone, once it has been checked against the rules of each destination the agency serves.

  • Course choice. Counsellor: which courses fit the student's grades, budget and plans. Refer: which course gives this person the best immigration outcome.
  • Documents. Counsellor: what the official checklist says and where it is published. Refer: whether this student's particular documents will be enough.
  • Funds. Counsellor: where the published requirement is and what the institution's costs add up to. Refer: whether this family's finances or sponsor arrangement will satisfy the rules.
  • Previous refusals. Counsellor: that the form asks about them and that the answer must be true. Refer: how to present a refusal, and whether to apply at all.
  • Visa route. Counsellor: the name of the student visa and its published conditions. Refer: which category suits this person, and any change of status.
  • Staying on. Counsellor: what is officially published about post-study work, with the link. Refer: whether this student will qualify, and how to plan for residence.
  • Dependants. Counsellor: that rules exist and where they are published. Refer: whether this spouse or child can come.
  • Problems. Counsellor: that the student must act quickly and needs proper advice. Refer: overstays, breaches of conditions, cancellations, reviews and appeals.

The pattern in every Refer entry is the word this. The moment a question contains this student, this family or this refusal, it has moved from what is published to what should be done, and that is the point to stop.

What staff say at the line.

The difficulty is social rather than legal. A counsellor who has built trust for six months does not want to say they cannot help. Give them the sentence in advance, and rehearse it.

That depends on your personal circumstances and the immigration rules, so I am not the right person to answer it. I can show you what the official checklist says, and I can refer you to a registered adviser who can answer it properly.

Two habits need stopping at the same time. The first is the reassurance that sounds like nothing: you will be fine, your case is strong. To a family, that is a professional opinion. The second is the answer given off the record, in a chat message or a corridor, because staff feel the rule is excessive. Off the record is still a statement made by the agency, and it is the one with no file note behind it.

A referral is a record.

A referral made by telling a student to find somebody is not a referral. Done properly it takes a few minutes per case.

  1. Keep a short list of registered or licensed advisers for each destination, checked against the official public register, with the date of the check.
  2. Note in the file what the student asked, that it fell outside what the agency could answer, and who they were referred to.
  3. Tell the student in writing that the adviser is independent, charges their own fee and answers for their own advice.
  4. Declare any referral arrangement. If the agency receives anything for sending students to an adviser, say so, or do better and accept nothing.
  5. Record the outcome that affects the application, without restating the adviser's advice as if it were your own.

The file note is what protects the counsellor. If a student later says the agency told them what to put on the form, a dated note showing that the question was referred is the difference between an awkward conversation and a serious one.

Decide which business you are in.

Some agencies decide visa work is central to what they sell and bring a registered adviser into the business, under whatever conditions that requires. Others refer, and are clear about it from the first meeting. Either is defensible. The position that is not defensible is the common one, where counsellors answer whatever they are asked because nobody has ever drawn the line.

At the next staff meeting, take the last twenty visa questions from the chat log and sort them into the two groups above, Counsellor and Refer. The longer group shows what kind of business the agency is actually running, whatever the sign on the door says.

Filed under

VisasReferralsCompliance

Immigration and institutional requirements change between intakes. Check the current official guidance for the destination before advising a family, and note the date you checked.

Where this lives in Visatory

Every visa step dated, and kept in the student's file.

Try it with your own students for 14 days. No card required, and your data exports if you leave.

Related reading.